| 8 |
Stu Scholl (4 times in cross country, 1972-75 and 4 times in track, 1973-76) |
|
|
| 7 |
Jilanne Bannink (4 times in cross country, 1987-90 and 3 times in swimming, 1988-91) |
| 7 |
Erin Herrmann (2 times in cross country, 2015 & 2016; 2 times in indoor track & field, 2016 & 2017; 3 times in outdoor track & field (2015, 2016 & 2017) |
| 7 |
Chelsea Miskelley (2 times in cross country, 17-18; 2 times in indoor track & field, 17 and 19; 3 times in outdoor track & field, 17-19) |
| 7 |
Steve Underwood (4 times in cross country, 1980-83 and 3 times in track, 1982-84) |
| 7 |
Holly VandenBerg (4 times in volleyball, 1986-89, 2 times in basketball, 1989-90, and 1 time in softball, 1987) |
|
|
| 6 |
Lindsey Dood (3 times in cross country, 1984-86 and 3 times in track, 1985-87) |
| 6 |
Nick Hoffman (1 time in cross country, 21; two times in outdoor track & field, 21 & 22; 3 times in indoor track & field, 19, 21, 22) |
| 6 |
Randy Johnson (4 times in cross country, 1984-87 and 2 times in track, 1987-88) |
| 6 |
Ellen Schultz (4 times in cross country, 1994-95-97-98 and 2 times in track, 1997-98) |
| 6 |
Marcia Vandersall (4 times in track, 1990-93 and 2 times in cross country, 1992-93) |
| 6 |
Kara Vande Gutche (4 times in track, 2008-11 and 2 times in volleyball, 2008 & 2009) |
|
|
| 5 |
Rick Bruggers (3 times in track, 1967-69 and 2 times in cross country, 1967-68) |
| 5 |
Phil Ceeley (4 times in cross country, 1971-74 and 1 time in track, 1975) |
| 5 |
Addyson Gerig (2 times in outdoor track & field, 18-19; 3 times in indoor track & field, 18-20) |
| 5 |
Karen Gingras-Hoekstra (3 times in basketball, 1984-85-86 and 2 times in track, 1985 & 1987) |
| 5 |
Kim Grotenhuis (3 times in softball, 1999-00-01 and 2 times in volleyball, 1999-00 |
| 5 |
Greg Heeres (3 times in football, 1982-84 and 2 times in baseball, 1983 and 1985) |
| 5 |
Lou Hoekstra (3 times in cross country, 1975-77 and 2 times in track, 1977-78) |
| 5 |
Tauna Jecmen (3 times in cross country, 1985-87-88 and 2 times in track, 1988-89) |
| 5 |
Avery Lowe (2 times in cross country, 15-16; 3 times in indoor track & field, 17-19) |
| 5 |
Nicki Mannes (3 times in softball, 1993-95 and 2 times in basketball, 1994-95) |
| 5 |
Sheri McCormack (3 times in track, 2012-14 and 2 times in cross country, 2011 & 2013) |
| 5 |
Dick Northuis (4 times in cross country, 1976-79 and 1 time in track, 1978) |
| 5 |
Mark Northuis (3 times in cross country, 1979-81 and 2 times in track, 1979-80) |
| 5 |
Don Piersma (2 times in football, 51-52; 3 times in baseball, 51-53 |
| 5 |
Tina Pike (3 times in cross country, 2002-03-04 and 2 times in track, 2004-05) |
| 5 |
Kenedy Schoonveld (5 times in basketball because of NCAA COVID exemption, 18-22) |
| 5 |
Mark Southwell (1 time in cross country, 1982 and 4 times in track, 1980-83) |
| 5 |
Emma Schaefer (5 times in swimming because of NCAA COVID exemption), 18-22) |
| 5 |
Rebecca Timmer (3 times in cross country, 1996-98 and 2 times in track, 1997 and 1999) |
| 5 |
Ana Tucker (2 times in cross country, 19 & 21; 2 times in indoor track & field, 21-22; 2 times in outdoor track & field, 21-22) |
| 5 |
Rachael Webb (1 time in cross country, 17; 2 times in indoor track & field, 16 &17) 2 times in outdoor track & field, 16 & 17) |
| 5 |
Nick Yonker (4 times in football, 1946-49 and 1 time in basketball, 1950) |
